Read my latest story, "The All-Nighter", at 52|250.

Needs is, hands down, the best episode yet of Dollhouse. I rarely say this, but I highly recommend that, if you haven’t seen it, you watch it before you read this or any other review, as much of the impact will be lost if you know what’s going to happen.

Two important themes were carried forward in Needs: the comparison of human with animal experimentation and the dollhouse as institutional enabler of rape. The first of these is most clearly addressed when Mr. Dominic suggests that the handlers view their actives as “pets” (which highlights that the very term “handler” often refers to a person in charge of an animal, though I would also note that very few people would put their pets in some of the positions the actives have been put in) and when the awakened Caroline compares their situation to that of lab rats. A somewhat less obvious connection is that Caroline, who in the previous episode sought to save lab animals, now seeks to save the human actives; this is what will give her closure. This similarity is expanded upon when Dr. Saunders argues that, had she not been sedated, Caroline would have led the other actives out into a world of terror for which they were not prepared: this is very similar to criticisms of animal rights activists who release creatures from cages into the wild. (Her argument isn’t entirely without merit given the state in which the actives are kept; we start to see the logic that has seduced the young doctor, assuming she had a choice in working for the dollhouse at all. Like Boyd Langton, we don’t know her very well.)

The second of these themes is explored through Sierra. We learn that she was not only raped by her former handler but was also brought to the dollhouse in the first place by a man, Nolan, who wanted to rape her. Dr. Saunders later says that Sierra needed to confront the man who took her power away. True enough. Given that she still has not taken back her power, however, the sense of closure taken from this should, to be realistic, only be temporary. Indeed, the dramatic arc of the series would seem to require this as well. The same could be said for all four of the actives’ resolutions.

While the significance of these themes should not be underestimated, they are not what gives this episode its emotional sweep and power. Rather, it is the well-constructed set of frames and machinations which shift our expectations and understandings. When the actives first awake, we of course cheer for them to escape. Even when we learn that Ms. DeWitt knows of the plan and is allowing it for the purposes of a “test”, we can still question how much is programmed and how much is real (though if you’re programmed with your real personality, unreal isn’t exactly an accurate description). Mr. Dominic at least believes there is no kill switch or safety net, so we hope for the actives to escape the boundaries of the experiment, even as we wonder why Adelle would really take such a risk. When we learn that Caroline has been programmed as Caroline-without-memories, we can still believe that the memories Sierra and November (Mellie) have recovered are outside the program. Even this is stolen from us in the end. Were it not for the call Caroline managed to place to Paul Ballard, the conclusion would be unbearably bleak.

The biggest reason for hope, however is something that even Dr. Saunders, who noticed the need for closure, misses: that if the strong needs of the original personalities can cause “glitches” then the original personality is never as overwritten as everyone who works for the dollhouse believes or pretends to believe.

For other perspectives on this episode visit:

• What’s Alan Watching?: Dollhouse, “Needs”: Caroline says
• Cultural Learnings: Dollhouse – “Needs”
• The Onion AV Club: “Needs”

ETA: Arturo R. García examines the roles of POC in Dollhouse at Racialicious.

ETA2: Fox has decided not to air the final episode of the first season of Dollhouse. If you’re a fan of the show and are on Twitter, tweet @FoxBroadcasting and ask them why.